Sonic Unleashed (Recompiled) ★★★☆☆

It’s interesting playing this after Shadow Generations; going back to the first boost game after the most recent one. They landed on a winning formula but there has been some clear and needed refinement over the years. The boost, homing attack and air dash all being the same button is a less than ideal and it lacks a good way to half your momentum quickly, the stomp transitioning into a slide when you’re moving quickly rather than stopping you dead line in later games. But it’s at its core familiar and fun territory for the day stages. Very familiar, actually, as I’ve played all of these levels before in Sonic Generations through mods and only now am experiencing them in their original context. It’s an interesting! There are definitely some gaps in the version presented by the Unleashed Project mod where the toolkit available to Sonic Generations modders could not replicate the original gameplay. On the other hand the original versions have fiddly and surprisingly unforgiving quick time events, so there are trade-offs whichever way one plays these levels.

For the night stages Sonic the Werehog is fairly fun. To begin with anyway. As the game wears on the combat increasingly overstays its welcome and while the platforming challenges can offer a breather they are generally not very interesting. Thankfully Unleashed Recompiled includes an option to turn off the battle music which helps with one of the more irritating aspects of the night levels. As a final nitpick I found the fact that all these Eggman’s robots and Dark Gaia monsters just hang out together and apparently work together in the night stages very odd. It feels like there should be a stronger dichotomy between the two types of enemies or even having them fight each other. Watching monster infighting is always fun!

Levels of both types can be pretty mean with bottomless pits and the like but the developers seemed to have at least noticed this and often put extra lives shortly after checkpoints before difficult sections.

Outside of the core gameplay the game does leave a lot to be desired. The world tour was a cute idea but the execution is tedious and a bit racist. It’s hard to ignore how western countries get towns and cities with levels that have you running through streets with human inhabitants, while elsewhere has small villages that you quickly leave to run through empty ruins (which you are also smashing up a fair bit), any significant construction or urban civilisation in these places being relegated to ancient history. When you arrive in Mazuri, based off Mali and other parts of Africa, you find yourself in a mudhut village devoid of any modern technology other than Eggman’s invading robots and one of the first people there you can speak to says something to the effect of “You’re looking for a professor. What’s that? Sounds tasty!” The one blessing is that when people are voiced they all just have American accents rather than any attempts to imitate different nationalities.

Even aside from all that going around and talking to people in general is a pain. Hub areas are littered with people but Sonic moves so sluggishly in them and no one ever has anything interesting to say, but there are times when you have to go around and mash buttons to advance their dialogue to the end in order to progress. That or go back to Professor Pickle’s lab fifty times only for him to tell you to go back to where you just were. It was only very late in the game that I realised that sometimes NPCs will give you challenge missions so there is actually reason to talk to them beyond reading them say inane crap. The fact that I had stopped talking to them whenever I didn’t have to meant I had probably missed a lot of those and did not help with my medal deficit.

You have to collect sun and moon medals to unlock stages and progress in the game. These are found scattered around both hub areas and levels and as long as you keep an eye out for them and make sure to collect them you can keep ahead of requirements for most of the game. I knew this going in and tried to be diligent but I still ended up hitting a brick wall on getting to Adabat (based on Cambodia and other parts of Southeast Asia) I had to go grind for sun medals for while before I could continue, which was tiresome and not helped by the fact that you can’t find medals or other collectables if you do the time trial or other challenge versions of levels, which at least might have let you do the grind with some more variety.

The plot is fairly insubstantial and dotted with comic relief characters who fail to ever be funny. Chip is Scrappy-Doo with pixie wings and proto-Orbot is even more annoying, ergo every cutscene with him in it is a pain to listen to, ergo I was annoyed every time I saw him, ergo I wish he wasn’t in this game.

Returning to the gameplay, the final level having you swap between both gameplay styles might have been cute if it was doing anything interesting with that, but it really is just day section, night section, day section repeatedly with one point where you can take a shortcut to stay in a day section for longer. I might have been tempted to replay the day parts if there was a way to do only them as it seems to have an interesting degree of branching paths that give it a feeling of semi-openness not seen in the rest of the game, but I do not want to go through the werehog sections of it again.

The final boss is… not the worst for a Sonic game. It’s passable. Like a lot of other things there’s some interesting ideas there that are lacking in execution.

For all its flaws this game did lay down a very solid foundation for the series going forward. Most of what is good about it was refined through future games and the worst parts of it were left by the wayside.